America shook Tuesday. Almost two years after Donald Trump’s rule by dictate began with a flood of executive orders Americans had enough. With our constitutional structure in tatters and a prostrate Congress and a supine Supreme Court offering slight checks on Trump, Americans raised their collective voice Tuesday and decided to invoke their power as a sovereign of this great nation. In a seismic tectonic shift, they set off a massive political earthshaking regime change in Congress, and in many red states as well.
Okay, Democrats, now that you caught the congressional bus, what are you going to do?
First, I offer, what you should not do.
While the political landscape has shifted and is disheveled, the Democrats should not confuse the midterm win with a mandate. The election was a rebuke of spineless Republicans in general, and Trump in particular. The midterm election was not an endorsement of the Democratic party; it was a yelp of frustration and anger, not a ringing endorsement of party.
As such, it is not a greenlight for Democrats to go hog wild, they should act with restraint. The results were mostly about Trump’s gross mismanagement of the economy, affordability, and failed promises, but it was also about Congress’s complete and utter capitulation to Trump.
They let Trump run wild like a bull at Pamplona’s famous running of the bulls; to rule America by edict, to let him vandalize the White House with golden shrines, our House, while keeping his hand in the nation’s cash drawer. It’s why we have the reckless and illegal Iran war and resulting energy shock of record high gas and diesel prices. Mostly they want a functioning Congress with a backbone, jealous of its powers and prerogatives, not a door mat.
Now, what should Democrats do?
Don’t screw it up. Hubris and overreach are every party’s Achilles heel when they win an election in a landslide.
Democrats should accept the results humbly, with grace, and reach out across the political aisle to moderate Republicans left standing. Republicans know that Trump and MAGA are 2028 liabilities if they want to retain the executive branch. Now is not the time to collect scalps or gaslight Republicans, instead offer a friendly hand, work with them. Make ‘compromise’ a byword once again of our democracy.
This election showed most Americans want common sense bipartisan legislation to address their economic concerns about stubborn inflation, stronger wage growth, cheaper credit. They are frustrated that they can’t get timely and affordable healthcare. They also are deeply concerned not only about datacenters but AI itself and the potential for massive social disruption and upheaval that appears ever closer. They want foreign adventures like Iran to stop. They want border security, but not the depraved, wanton cruelty and violence perpetrated by ICE thugs against the denizens of America. Mostly they want the economy to serve them, not solely the billionaires or the investment class.
The legislative agenda of the next Congress should be robust and prioritize America’s middle class. Impeaching Trump should not be a goal. Instead, box him in like a good Congress can and should. For starters, claw back the power of the purse, take away a president’s power to levy tariffs and make wars. No more Trump Supreme Court nominees confirmed in the next two years.
Place a moratorium on congressional investigations. American’s want legislative results not perpetual cycles of investigations. They are fatigued by endless tit-for-tat congressional investigations. Yes, have hearings to hold Trump and his administration accountable to the People, but enough with the investigations, focus all your time and energy on righting the congressional ship, restoring the rule of law. Criminal investigations of Trump and members of his administration can come later, after the 2028 elections.
Finally, new leadership is needed, especially in the Senate. Democrats must set their broad differences (and egos) aside and not devolve into internecine party warfare, which they seem want to do at times. Dysfunction and failure to govern are not an option in the next two years. If the Democratic controlled congress descends into legislative chaos and infighting, it will result in another Republican in the White House. The Democrats can start by showing Schumer the legislative leadership door. He must go. As for Jeffries, I am agnostic, he is learning and he is, importantly, young.
Democrats must capitalize on their electoral victories in Congress and many states. But, and this is a big but, have a measured, thoughtful response. You don’t have a mandate, this is an audition for 2028. Bipartisanship and compromise must be guiding principles to regain the trust of the People. Don’t blow it Democrats.