Tag: Smithsonian Museums

The Minstrel Show Presidency

“The Smithsonian is OUT OF CONTROL, where everything discussed is how horrible our Country is, how bad Slavery was, and how unaccomplished the downtrodden have been — Nothing about Success, nothing about Brightness, nothing about the Future,” 

President Donald Trump, 2025

Ignorance is strength I suppose.  Trump, perhaps the least read and most historically illiterate president this country has ever had, continues his campaign of whitewashing American history.  Trump’s sole understanding of slavery, it appears, is informed by Disney’s “Song of the South.”. A dated and romanticized depiction of slavery.  The Trump White House is theater, an increasingly odd mix of minstrel show and Nuremberg Rally.  

According to Merriam-Webster’s dictionary, a museum is “an institution devoted to the procurement, care, study, and display of objects of lasting interest or value.”   It should include ‘interpretation’ as well.  But it is essentially correct in that it preserves things ‘of lasting interest and value.’ 

In America, that meant museums sidelining, excluding, or denigrating peoples and their cultural objects that did not conform to America’s myths of exceptionalism and manifest destiny, that shiny white city on the hill.  Reducing the ‘other’ to an asterixis of history.  More heritage and nostalgia than history.

The National Museum of the American Indian and the National Museum of African American History and Culture were remedies for this deliberate exclusion from America’s origin myths. Trump, however, wants to return America to a dated interpretation of our history by recasting the Smithsonian’s museum’s interpretations of our history back through the white male gaze.

Our history is complex with many paradoxes, for instance slavery and freedom.  But one can’t speak to the future without knowing where we came from.  America must confess to the sin of slavery before it can move on.  Slavery was and is bad and showing slavery for what it was and is should not be controversial.  Enlightened and benevolent plantation slave masters did not exist.   A mature country, sure of itself and its future, acknowledges its horrific failures as well as its great successes. Obviously, despite his MAGA moniker, Trump really does not believe in America’s potential for greatness or future as a thriving pluralistic democracy.

Over generations, millions endured brutal dehumanizing conditions: Sexual assaults, beatings, whippings, amputations as punishment, malnutrition, murders, executions, burnings, hangings, forced sales and separations of children, wives, and husbands.  This system of violence and oppression became the cornerstone America’s economic system from its founding to 1865. America was not merely a country with slaves, but a slave society.  

African American history is American history.  Africans were in North America even before the English, arriving as explorers with the Spanish.  The first permanent presence of folks of African descent in English settlements arrived in 1619 near Jamestown, Virginia.  With them came new foodways, new cosmologies, new medicines, new music, new cultural infusions that make us what we are today:  American. 

African American history is larger and more complex than just the institution of slavery, however.  It’s a story about agency, determination, family, resilience, survival, and even thriving in the face of relentless state sanctioned violence to oppress and control.

If you are interested in your own further readings on the subject, below is my list of books that I think are worth a close read. The list is far from complete and is not meant as a comprehensive historiography of America’s ‘peculiar institution’ but merely a starting point for further exploration.   They are not listed in any order, but there is a distinct Virginia tilt.

Hugh Thomas, The Slave Trade: The Story of the Atlantic Slave Trade, 1440-1870. An excellent primer on the Atlantic Slave trade.

The Old Dominion in the Seventeenth Century: A Documentary History of Virginia, 1606-1689. Edited by Warren M. Billings.  Traces Virginia’s establishment and legal evolution of race-based slavery through statutory acts.  For example, in December 1662, Virginia’s General Assembly passed a law stating that “all children borne in this country shalbe held bond [slave] or free only according to the condition of the mother.”

Edmund S. Morgan, American Slavery — American Freedom: The Ordeal of Colonial Virginia.  Argues that colonial Virginia’s long and deep experience with slavery is a central paradox in America’s revolutionary demands for freedom from English “slavery.”

Ira Berlin, Many Thousands Gone: The First Two Centuries of Slavery in North America. Traces the transformation of society with slaves to a slave society and back again and how the relationship between enslaved and free continuously remodeled over time.   

Herbert Aptheker, American Negro Slave Revolts.  First published in 1943, it was part of a growing academic response and challenge to Columbia University’s ‘Dunning School’ of historical interpretation that originated in the late 19th century.  This ‘school’ dominated scholarly discourse on Reconstruction and policies and laws in the Jim Crow South well into the 1930s.  The Dunning school defended racist laws that oppressed African Americans using arguments based on ‘scientific racism’ then popular in the late 19thcentury.  For more on ‘scientific racism’ see Stephen Gould’s excellent book Mismeasure of Man.

Douglas Egerton, Gabriel’s Rebellion: The Virginia Slave Conspiracies of 1800 and 1802. An excellent account of the attempted rebellion by a Gabriel in Henrico County and its aftermath.

Zora Neale Hurston, Barracoon: The Story of the Last “Black Cargo. From Hurston’s 1927 interview of Oluale Kossala, the last survivor of the Clotilda, the last documented slave ship to carry captive Africans to American shores in 1860.  The book is a fascinating retelling of Kossala’s life in Africa before his harrowing capture and transport to the U.S., his subsequent enslavement (renamed Cudjo Lewis) and life after emancipation.  Of note, the remains of the Clotilda were discovered in 2019.

The Slave Classic Slave Narratives: The life of Olaudah Equiano, The History of Mary Prince, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl, Edited by Henry Louis Gates, Jr.  

Charles Ball, Fifty Years in Chains or the Life of an American Slave.  Excellent first-person narrative.  The story of Chales Ball is extraordinary. A truly epic account of loss and resilience and hope.  An American version of the Iliad.

Annette Gordon-Reed, The Heminges of Monticello: An American Family.  A superb recounting of the Heminges family history while enslaved by Thomas Jefferson.  Flips the script of telling the story of slavery from the perspective of the enslaver to that of the enslaved taking center stage.

Adam Rothman, Slave Country: American Expansion and the Origins of the Deep South.  Explores the reasons why America’s revolutionary generation – the ones screaming loudly about being slaves of the English and all the enlightenment language on equality – did not abolish slavery, but expanded it under their watch in the early Republic.

Tiya Miles, All that She Carried: The Journey of Ashley’s Sack, A Black Family Keepsake.  A beautifully written cultural history of a canvas sack and its contents given to a daughter by her mother after her child was sold.  The canvas bag survived the vagaries of time.  If you read one book from this list, this is it.

Walter Johnson, Soul by Soul: Life in the Antebellum Slave Market.  It’s a story of the slave showrooms in New Orleans, how being on the sale block was negotiated from the perspective of the enslaved and the slave holder.  Excellent read.

Steven Deyle, Carry Me Back: The Domestic Slave Trade in American Life, and Michel Tadman, Speculators and Slaves: Masters, Traders, and Slave in the Old South.  Two excellent studies on America’s domestic slave trade which developed after the constitutional ban on the importation of slaves after 1807.  This ban, in conjunction with America’s Westward movement, sparked a massive internal slave trade from Virginia and North Carolina to the ‘deep south.’

Alan Taylor, The Internal Enemy: Slavery and War in Virginia, 1772 – 1832.  This is the story of those enslaved African Americans that fought with the British to gain their freedom.  

Jonathan Daniel Wells, The Kidnapping Club:  Wall Street, Slavery, and Resistance on the Eve of the Civil War.  A story of northern complicity in perpetuating slavery for Wall Street profit. How New York City cops, courts, lawyers, judges, and politicians conspired with southern slave owners and slave catchers to kidnap free blacks and capture runaway slaves and send them South.   

David Waldstreicher, Slavery’s Constitution:  From Revolution to Ratification.  The author cogently and convincingly argues that “slavery was as important to the making of the Constitution as the Constitution was to the survival of slavery.”  While one won’t ever find the word ‘slave’ or ‘slavery’ in the constitution, there are at least 11 clauses that directly or indirectly concern slavery. 

M. M. Manring, Slave in a Box: The Strange Career of Aunt Jemima.  A provocative book that explores the legacy of slavery and racial subservience in America’s consumer revolution in the late 19th century.  You won’t walk down the aisles of a supermarket or watch a commercial on TV or streaming the same way after reading this book.

As we careen wildly and OUT OF CONTROL towards an authoritarian government, reading will become an act of resistance.  Please share this list with your friends and family.

Liberation Day: A Real Story

Where does one start this week’s essay on democracy’s erosion in America?  Do I focus on the criminalization of dissent in America?  Should the latest threats of national guard and military deployments to democratic party led cities such as Chicago and New York lead this week?  Or, perhaps, should the essay focus on Trump’s outrageous observation that slavery is being misrepresented by the nation’s premier museum system, the Smithsonian.  Is there a positive argument for slavery…..ever? All part of his re-erasure of American history that includes people of non-European heritage.  All that will be left of ‘official’ American history will be reinvented myths of dead white men.

I want to tell an authentic American story of liberation instead.

About a decade ago a cousin of mine, a doctor in residence at a military hospital on an Air Force base, was asked by a fellow resident if he was related to so-and-so.  His response, ‘Yes, he was my grandfather.’ The follow up was startling.  The name, he said, comes from his family’s lore.  My grandfather, he revealed, rescued his family from certain death in a Nazis concentration camp.

This story of escape from death added an hitherto unknown dimension to my grandfather’s experiences during the second world war.  His division, the 104th, landed at Normandy a couple weeks after D-day in 1944.  In April 1945, his division helped liberate a slave labor concentration camp in Nordhausen, Germany.  

According to my father, my grandfather never talked about the war, and not about Nordhausen in particular.  The story of his father being a ‘hero’ of a Jewish family was new to him and brought tears to his eyes.  My father never cries.  While my grandfather did not talk much about the war, he did, however, write a description of what he witnessed at Nordhausen for the Minneapolis Star, based on a letter dated from April 5.  Eighty years later they have not lost their punch and graphic images of that day:

“…….. I visited a town called Nordhausen where I saw the most horrible sights.  You may have read about it or seen pictures.  We overran a German concentration camp.  It was filled with thousands of dead and half-dead POW’s and political prisoners.  The bodies of the dead were unburied.  Others were lying in rows and beds where they had died, most of them from starvation.  The fields, for over a mile were strewn with bodies where the SS had mowed them down with machine guns.”  He continued, “the living were mixed with the dead – too weak and too far gone to move.  Several died while our medics were taking them to the hospital.  Nearly 3500 unburied bodies were found, many which with evidence of torture before death, nearly all starved.”  Observing that he had heard of such places before arriving a Nordhausen he added, “I have read stories of such places but never thought I would see such a thing as I did.  Since then we have had reports of other camps that have been over run – nearly as bad.  But I have seen enough…the brutality and inhumanity of the German SS Troops is beyond belief….If I had not seen the results with my own eyes.”  I have his map that traces his unit’s route, with cities and towns they liberated — circled in red pencil — as they moved east.

One can only imagine what my cousin’s fellow doctor’s family must have endured.

That two grandsons – one from an American soldier and another from a survivor of a liberated nazi concentration camp – both bound by that same day in history, would meet by chance somewhere in the American mid-west some 70 years later is astonishing.  

Furthermore, that same month in 1945, 600 kilometers directly to the north, my mom, then a girl of six, and her family were liberated from five years of Nazi occupation.  While my grandfather is long dead and only his writings remain of that fateful month, my mom still lives.  She doesn’t remember much about the German occupation, mostly recalling food rationing, but I think mostly because the occupation was relatively calm.  The Danes surrendered quickly and the occupation mostly uneventful.  The Danes weren’t ethnic ‘Slavs’ and thus spared the rage and violence that enveloped Poland, the Ukraine and eastern Russia.  Still, she remembers the trucks coming for suspected collaborators that lived nearby after liberation. She fears Trump, and with good reason, it seems.

My grandfather was asked to stay on active duty after the war, rising through the ranks. His career was abruptly dead ended, however, when he was accused of communist sympathies during the McCarthy era.   It seems that his running for mayor of Minneapolis in the 1930s as a candidate of the Farmer-Labor Party had attracted attention once again.  In 1953, the army reopened old, pre-war accusation of his alleged communist sympathies and weeks before the McCarthy hearings focusing on the army started, the Army purged him from their ranks, recommending his dismissal and removed from command.  He was eventually reinstated after appeal, promoted to Colonel, but was exiled to the Reserve Officer Training Corps at the University of Alaska for the remainder of his career.

Purges, massive interment and concentration camps, masked government agents, disappearances, politically directed criminal investigations, erasing of peoples histories, military occupation of the capital, and collapse of the constitutional system. They are not theoretical constructs, they are real and here today. For me it is all too personal.

Today, our country stands at a fork in the road, one diverging right to authoritarian rule, perhaps even fascist rule, the other, the well-trod path pathway of democracy now seemingly blocked, detour signs pointing right.  My family’s roots scream at me to resist the lurch to the far, extreme right, with everything I have.   My grandfather words about the  “…the brutality and inhumanity of the German SS Troops is beyond belief….If I had not seen the results with my own eyes” speak to me clearly.  We must not cease resisting, we must not cease caring, we must not give up.  

We are heading down that path of brutality and inhumanity where so-called ‘superfluous’ peoples are erased.  But we can stop it dead in its tracks if we stay engaged and active as wave after wave of Trumpian bullshit tries to overwhelm and batter us into submission.

This mean calling your representatives weekly or daily if needed, join protest/resistance groups, make resistance artwork, spread the word, donate to campaigns, write a blog, vote.  Don’t let the fascist bastards get you down.   Let us walk together down that road to democracy together. Please share this essay. Thanks.